1st Energy vs Red Energy

1st Energy is cheaper - by about $200/year

1st Energy’s cheapest residential electricity plan, 1st Emerald, Residential - Time of Use with Controlled Load, costs an estimated $1,003/year at 4,000 kWh, 32% below the VDO. Red Energy’s cheapest plan, Red BCNA, costs $1,203/year, 21% below the VDO. That is a difference of $200/year - switching from Red Energy to 1st Energycould save you about that much, though your actual cost depends on your usage, tariff type and eligibility for any plan’s conditional discounts.

1st Energy - cheapest plans

Rank by:
PlanRetailerAnnual cost ▲at 4,000 kWh/yr
1st Energy logo
1st Emerald, Residential - Time of Use with Controlled Load
Time of use
1st Energy$1,003
Switch
1st Energy logo
1st Emerald, Residential - Time of Use
Time of use
1st Energy$1,003
Switch
1st Energy logo
1st Emerald, Residential - Time of Use with Controlled Load
Time of use
1st Energy$1,016
Switch
Showing 3 of 3 plans. Click column headers to sort.

Red Energy - cheapest plans

Rank by:
PlanRetailerAnnual cost ▲at 4,000 kWh/yr
Red Energy logo
Red BCNA
Flat rate
Red Energy$1,203
Switch
Red Energy logo
Red BCNA
Flat rate
Red Energy$1,203
Switch
Red Energy logo
Red Rotary D9815 Saver
Flat rate
Red Energy$1,203
Switch
Showing 3 of 3 plans. Click column headers to sort.

Head-to-head: cheapest plan from each retailer

Spec1st EnergyRed Energy
Plan1st Emerald, Residential - Time of Use with Controlled LoadRed BCNA
Supply charge83.60c/day94.80c/day
Usage rate26.40c/kWh (peak)21.43c/kWh
Exit fee$0.00$0.00
Contract termNo lock-inNo lock-in
Green energy--
Solar feed-in tariff0.5c/kWh1.0c/kWh

How do I switch from 1st Energy to Red Energy?

Choose a plan above and click Switch. Bill Hero lodges the transfer with your new retailer - there is no interruption to your electricity supply, and most switches complete within 2 business days. 1st Energy’s cheapest plan has no lock-in contract and an exit fee of $0.00; Red Energy’s has no lock-in contract and an exit fee of $0.00. Check your current plan’s exit fee before switching, if any applies.

Frequently asked questions

Is 1st Energy or Red Energy cheaper?
1st Energy has the cheaper residential electricity plan of the two, by an estimated $200/year at 4,000 kWh usage. Your actual saving depends on your usage and tariff - compare the plans above for exact numbers.
How do I switch from 1st Energy to Red Energy?
Choose a Red Energy plan above and click Switch. Bill Hero manages the switch for you - there's no interruption to supply, and most switches complete within 2 business days. The same process applies in reverse for switching from Red Energy to 1st Energy.
Does 1st Energy or Red Energy charge an exit fee?
Neither 1st Energy's nor Red Energy's cheapest residential plan charges an exit fee, based on current Consumer Data Right (CDR) data.

Related comparisons